Who's the best young QB in the league?

[Willie99]

The choices

 

[PatsFan1283]

What is young? inside of 3 years?

Carson Wentz

 

[HacheMan]

Goff

 

[JustinCruise]

Goff

Lol

 

[JustinCruise]

Its Mahommes and not close

 

[HacheMan]

Its Mahommes and not close

Ridiculous

He's played 3 games.

Wentz & Goff have proven much more.

 

[PatsFan1283]

Its Mahommes and not close

Yeah, maybe.

I guess the point of the thread is to answer the question in a forward thinking way, not based on resume. Which I defaulted to doing.

Wentz tore up the league pretty bad last year before his injury though. I guess people will say they won the SB w/o him as a knock but he was dominating.

 

[JustinCruise]

Yeah, maybe.

I guess the point of the thread is to answer the question in a forward thinking way, not based on resume. Which I defaulted to doing.

Wentz tore up the league pretty bad last year before his injury though. I guess people will say they won the SB w/o him as a knock but he was dominating.

Not close to the level of domination we are seeing with Mahommes

 

[Willie99]

WTF? Give me a chance to set up the poll boys

 

[HacheMan]

wtf? Give me a chance to set up the poll boys

lol

 

[PatsFan1283]

It's been 3 games with a stacked supporting cast and a fairly easy schedule. And Alex Smith was getting MVP hype with this crew after 6-7 weeks last year (Alex Smith!)

Maybe he is the best though. Even when they reach their primes, it will still be subjective since so much of football is based on coaching/supporting cast.

 

[JustinCruise]

It's been 3 games with a stacked supporting cast and a fairly easy schedule. And Alex Smith was getting MVP hype with this crew after 6-7 weeks last year (Alex Smith!)

Maybe he is the best though. Even when they reach their primes, it will still be subjective since so much of football is based on coaching/supporting cast.

His team has probably the worst defense in the NFL

Legit chance to break the season long TD record as a rookie

 

[Willie99]

I really don't think many people are going to pick the $ 135 million dollar boy

I went with the guy I liked best out of college, Josh Allen, but there are several great choices

 

[JustinCruise]

I really don't think many people are going to pick the $ 135 million dollar boy

I went with the guy I liked best out of college, Josh Allen, but there are several great choices

So if you're a GM and have the choice of any of these guys you take Josh Allen? Yea ok.


Starting to question that tax advice you gave me Willie


Just kidding :toast:

 

[Willie99]

What is young? inside of 3 years?

Carson Wentz

I know, Jimmy G might be too old for this poll

And you're only allowed 8 options, otherwise I throw Trubisky in the mix. He could be a write-in candidate

 

[Willie99]

So if you're a GM and have the choice of any of these guys you take Josh Allen? Yea ok.


Starting to question that tax advice you gave me Willie


Just kidding :toast:

He looked just as good in his one start as Mahomes has looked in his whopping three starts

And he doesn't have the talent Mahomes is surrounded with

 

[CHOPTALK]

Josh Allen actually has an even stronger arm then Mahomes .

As a matter of fact he has about the strongest arm of any qb I’ve ever seen not named Jamarcus Russell

 

[Willie99]

If Vlad were here, he'd pick Watson

 

[CHOPTALK]

There is no doubt Allen has the most ability .

But ability is not everything .

Drew Brees and Tom Brady don’t have the physical skill of probably 25 other starters in this league but both are all time greats

 

[JustinCruise]

If Vlad were here, he'd pick Watson

Lmao